Advertisement
I rented an excellent noir from the local library, “Nightmare Alley,” (1947), starring Tyrone Power. Just the title is enough to provoke images of dark corridors and scary back alleys. And, the title never disappoints, even though there are no alleys or thugs with knifes in the film. In this absorbing story, based on the novel by William Lindsey Gresham, we have Tyrone Power playing Stanton Carlisle a huckster working in the carnival. He learns the tricks of mind reading from Zeena (Joan Blondell) and then dumps her. He then leaves the carnival and begins working in ritzy nightclubs as “The Great Stanton.” But his elevated status as the darling of society doesn’t last forever as his infamy, built on lies, begins to collapse.
Directed by Edmund Goulding, with the screenplay written by Jules Furthman, this excellent noir is great at portraying both the carnies and high society as corrupt. We see both as Stanton moves into the upper classes. He begins seeing a psychiatrist, Lillith played by Helen Walker who plays a femme fatal who is both unethical and dishonest.
There is a wonderful scene where Stanton visits the psychiatrist in her office and the lighting fixtures cast dark lines on the walls symbolizing a spider web and the Doctor as a spider woman trapping Stanton in her web of deceit.
Tyrone’s character is both conniving and greedy but still likeable perhaps because he’s not malicious. He is a flawed character whose pride prevents him from avoiding his downfall. His enterprise is doomed to failure as he refuses to listen to those who care about him. When Zeena looks to her Tarot cards to predict Stanton’s future she turns up both the Hanged Man and the Death Card. He blows her off exclaiming the cards are for suckers.
As great as Stanton is at his con his game can’t last forever and exposure eventually sends his world crumbling down around him. And, that possibly is the overall theme of this superb film noir: one can easily fall apart and wind up in despair. Perhaps no one is too far from being the Geek in the carnival.
There are three beautiful women in the film (Joan Blondell, Coleen Gray, and Helen Walker), each with significant roles. Each one gets involved with Stanton but the romance is never smarmy or gooey sweet like so many female roles back in the day. And,Tyrone Power as Stanton is great as a greedy big shoot who puts on a melodramtic flair to convince his clients that his mind-reading act is for real.
This is one of the best noirs I've seen lately and I highly recommend it.
Directed by Edmund Goulding, with the screenplay written by Jules Furthman, this excellent noir is great at portraying both the carnies and high society as corrupt. We see both as Stanton moves into the upper classes. He begins seeing a psychiatrist, Lillith played by Helen Walker who plays a femme fatal who is both unethical and dishonest.
There is a wonderful scene where Stanton visits the psychiatrist in her office and the lighting fixtures cast dark lines on the walls symbolizing a spider web and the Doctor as a spider woman trapping Stanton in her web of deceit.
Tyrone’s character is both conniving and greedy but still likeable perhaps because he’s not malicious. He is a flawed character whose pride prevents him from avoiding his downfall. His enterprise is doomed to failure as he refuses to listen to those who care about him. When Zeena looks to her Tarot cards to predict Stanton’s future she turns up both the Hanged Man and the Death Card. He blows her off exclaiming the cards are for suckers.
As great as Stanton is at his con his game can’t last forever and exposure eventually sends his world crumbling down around him. And, that possibly is the overall theme of this superb film noir: one can easily fall apart and wind up in despair. Perhaps no one is too far from being the Geek in the carnival.
There are three beautiful women in the film (Joan Blondell, Coleen Gray, and Helen Walker), each with significant roles. Each one gets involved with Stanton but the romance is never smarmy or gooey sweet like so many female roles back in the day. And,Tyrone Power as Stanton is great as a greedy big shoot who puts on a melodramtic flair to convince his clients that his mind-reading act is for real.
This is one of the best noirs I've seen lately and I highly recommend it.
posted by:
|
|
Unsubscribed |
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Re: Nightmare Alley (1947)
Thu, May 11, 2006 - 2:25 PMCompletely, absolutely agree. "Nightmare Alley" is one of the best film noirs, and one of Power's finest performances ("Razor's Edge" is the other.)
Just thinking about it now, it's probably the closest we've had to a Lon Chaney picture since
Lon C. Sr. died in 1930. -
-
Re: Nightmare Alley (1947)
Sat, May 13, 2006 - 6:41 AMgot a chance to see Nightmare Alley on the big screen- it was not perfect
but a darned good flick and it was fun seeing it on the big screen -
-
Unsu...
Re: Nightmare Alley (1947)
Sat, May 13, 2006 - 7:13 AMJoan Blondell is just great. Love her. Will have to look for this movie.
-
-
-
Re: Nightmare Alley (1947)
Tue, May 16, 2006 - 9:51 AMNightmare Alley has been unavailable for years, so its great to see it has been released on DVD. Here's an interesting bit of trivia about the film: It is based on a novel of the same title, writtien by William Gresham. Gresham was married to a woman named Joy, and after his death, Joy Gresham moved to England and met the writer CS Lewis, the author of the Narnia Stories. She and Lewis bacame friends, and after she was diagnosed with terminal cancer, he married her and adopted her children (this is effectivel dramatized in the movie Shadowlands, with Anthony Hopkins and Debra Winger). Upon Lewis's death, Joy's two sons inherited his estate, including his copyrights. So this takes us to the present, where these two now grown middle aged men now control the copyrights on both Nightmare Alley, an extremely hard boiled, cynical noir masterpiece that ridicules religious fakery and the Narnia Stories, a delightful if at times overly didactic retelling of the Christian myth as a proper British fairy tale. -
-
Unsu...
Re: Nightmare Alley (1947)
Tue, May 16, 2006 - 9:45 PMRichard,
that's a fascinating bit of trivia. I didn't know that. I have to quibble about one point. Richard said, "Nightmare Alley is an extremely hard boiled, cynical noir masterpiece that ridicules religious fakery." I haven't read the novel but have you actually seen the film?
I don't think it pokes fun of religious fakery. In fact the film takes a rather neutral stance. There are time where Tyrone Power's character actually displays the power of mind-reading. For instance, when the local sheriff tries to bust up the carnival, Powers steps in acts like a mind-reader telling the sheriff many things about the law officers' home life. Some are pure coincidence but some are not. In other words, there's no way Powers could know some of these things he says unless he possessed some sort of "gift." And, part of what leads to Powers' downfall is the fact that he DOESN'T believe in his Tarot card reading.
I'm not putting you down or anything, its just that I disagree with your statement about the story. That's all. And its ALL good!
-
-
Re: Nightmare Alley (1947)
Thu, May 18, 2006 - 11:18 PMI agree, it's a brilliant movie. One of the best stories I've ever seen about con-artistry, trickery, quackery, and why people get fooled.
Aside from the excellent plot machinations, I think Tyrone Power really did some fine acting in this one. -
-
Re: Nightmare Alley (1947)
Sun, January 14, 2007 - 1:25 PMWatched this gem of a movie early this a.m. What can I say? Except it's terrific and holds up well after 60 years.
The photography is something else, like heavy contrasting of shadow with partially lit faces, etc. and the framing of the main players with supporting cast. The directing is tight, with no flab, and of course from Powers to the supporting cast the acting is superb and believable.
And Joan Blondell and Colleen Gray were beautiful.
-
